Ask a wellness collaborator what they want in a score and the answer often arrives as a number: 432, 528, 396. Ask what the number means and the answers diverge wildly. This is the version I give them, and the version I would want if I were licensing a work for a film or a retreat.

Where the numbers actually come from

The set marketed as “Solfeggio” — 396, 417, 528, 639, 741, 852 and the extensions around them — was put together in the twentieth century. The most repeated story traces it to Joseph Puleo's claimed rediscovery in the 1970s, worked out by reading passages in the biblical Book of Numbers as a code. Leonard G. Horowitz later popularised it, co-publishing Healing Codes for the Biological Apocalypse in 1999 with Joseph E. Barber — the name Puleo appears under.

This matters because the marketing usually leans on antiquity. The medieval system of solfège — do, re, mi and the rest, linked to Guido d'Arezzo — is a way of teaching pitch relationships. It is not a documented list of frequencies measured in hertz, and no liturgical manuscript hands down a 528 Hz tuning standard. A set built from modern numerology deserves to be described as exactly that.

What the 528 Hz evidence measured

You will see 528 Hz described as the frequency that repairs DNA. The study behind that phrase is a 2017 lab experiment by Babayi and Riazi. They exposed human astrocyte cells grown in a dish — first treated with ethanol — to 528 Hz sound. Under those conditions, the cells survived better and showed less of the cell damage that unstable molecules cause (oxidative stress). That is a narrow cell-culture result. It does not show that listening to 528 Hz repairs DNA in a person, and cell-survival tests are a long way from a clinical outcome.

Water-crystal claims are a separate thread, and they often get mixed in. The triple-blind study by Radin and colleagues — with Masaru Emoto as a co-author — tested whether distant intention changed aesthetic ratings of ice-crystal photographs under its protocol. It did not test 528 Hz audio, and it did not show water memory or any clinical effect. Citing it as evidence for healing frequencies misstates what was measured.

A=432 against A=440, without the mythology

A=440 Hz is the modern standard reference pitch. A=432 Hz is a deliberate alternative about thirty-two cents lower — roughly a third of a semitone, or about 1.8 per cent. You can hear the difference in an A/B test, and in musical terms it is small.

Historical tuning really did vary between regions and centuries, but the claim that ancient civilisations all used A=432 is not supported by the sources. On health, a 2019 study compared music tuned to 440 versus 432 Hz. It reported slightly lower heart rate and blood pressure after the 432 Hz condition, but the sample was very small and people were not randomly assigned to each group. Expectation and ordinary relaxation cannot be separated from any tuning effect. It is a hypothesis worth studying, not a property of a number.

A reference pitch is a compositional decision. It is not a medical intervention.

What tuning discipline actually buys

There are real reasons I keep working with these references, and none of them need a metaphysical claim.

  • Tuning discipline. Committing to A=432 forces you to account for every source that assumes 440 — sampled instruments, synth presets, vocals tuned in another session. That audit almost always improves intonation across the record.
  • Planning registers for long-form work. Works built around 432 and 528 Hz put drones and bell partials in specific, repeatable ranges. That consistency lets a facilitator stack a forty-minute session from different pieces without clashes — a practical need in sound-journey and ecstatic dance programming.
  • How overtones behave. Singing bowls, gongs and bells have overtones that do not line up in neat whole-number steps, so they beat against fixed drones. Choosing the reference pitch first, instead of discovering it in the mix, decides whether those beats read as shimmer or as mud.
  • Client language. Wellness and film collaborators often arrive with frequency language already in the project notes. Meeting that vocabulary while scoping honestly — “here is what the work does, here is what we are not claiming” — builds the trust that leads to repeat work.
  • Licensing clarity. Documenting tuning in delivery notes means sync partners and mastering engineers know exactly what they received. Ambiguity here causes releases, not conversations.

How I work with it in practice

  • Decide the reference pitch at the start of the project and document it in the session notes and delivery sheet.
  • Do not destructively retune sample libraries. Use a pitch offset per track where it is musical, and save wholesale retuning for material you own outright.
  • Keep equal temperament in mind. A tuned drone plus a piano is a clash between natural tuning and the evenly spaced tuning a piano uses, not a frequency problem — check thirds and fifths by ear.
  • Deliver both tunings when a partner needs 440 Hz. Sync licensing, broadcast and larger labels often specify standard pitch, and an alternate master costs minutes.
  • Keep the liner notes honest. Describe intention, texture and practice — not therapeutic outcomes.

The same discipline applies to immersive work. An adaptive score for a plant-based ceremony or a breathwork room may sit at 432 Hz for an hour with almost no harmonic movement, so the tuning has to be settled before the first drone is printed. In a three-minute instrumental the choice is one decision among dozens; in an hour-long ritual it is the floor everything else stands on.

Why this is the commercially safer position

A catalogue that says “tuned to a 528 Hz reference, in dialogue with Solfeggio practice, cleared for classes and film” can be licensed and resold without anyone being able to call it false. A catalogue that promises DNA repair invites exactly the scrutiny that ends a wellness brand. The music is strong enough to stand on texture, tuning discipline and craft — and those are things I can deliver in every session.